|
Sign In to gain access to subscriptions and/or personal tools.
|
Duty and 'Euthanasia': the Nurses of Meseritz-Obrawalde
Susan Benedict
Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC, USA, benedics{at}musc.edu
Arthur Caplan
University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA
Traute Lafrenz Page
Yonges Island, SC, USA
This article examines the actions and testimonies of 14 nurses who killed psychiatric patients at the state hospital of Meseritz-Obrawalde in the Nazi 'euthanasia' program. The nurses provided various reasons for their decisions to participate in the killings. An ethical analysis of the testimonies demonstrates that a belief in the relief of suffering, the notion that the patients would 'benefit' from death, their selection by physicians for the 'treatment' of 'euthanasia', and a perceived duty to obey unquestioningly the orders of physicians were the primary ethical reasons that were stated for their behavior. However, 20 years had elapsed between the killings and the trial, thus giving ample opportunity for the defendants to develop comfortable rationales for their actions and for their attorneys to have observed successful defenses of others accused of euthanasia.
Key Words: ethics • euthanasia • Nazi • psychiatry
References
- Trial of Hans-Joachim Becker and Friedrich Robert Lorent, Ks 1/69 (GStA), 27 May 1970, Landgericht Frankfurt: 721. File location: Documentation Centre of Austrian Resistance (DÖW), Vienna (in German).
- Friedlander, H. The origins of Nazi genocide. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 1995: 151.
- Burleigh, M. Death and deliverance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995: 149.
- Dramowicz, Waldemar. Obrzyce, Mi
 dzyrzecz. 2004 [A history of Meseritz-Obrawalde: no other details available] (in Polish) - Sagel-Grande I., Fuchs H., Rüter, C. Heil- und Pflegeanstalt Meseritz-Obrawalde; Justiz und NS-Verbrechen. (Care and nursing institution Meseritz-Obrawalde; Justice and National Socialist Criminal Records.) Vol. XX, 1979. Amsterdam: University Press Amsterdam, 1979: 700 (in German).
- Statement of Hilde Wernicke, Landesgericht, Berlin, December 7, 1945. File location: Jerusalem, Yad Vashem, file number TR 10/2584 (in German).
- Ebbinghaus A. Opfer und Täterinnen. (Sacrifice and perpetrator.) Nördlingen: Delphi Poiliti, 1987: 224 (in German).
- Statement of Hilde Wernicke, Landesgericht, Berlin, December 7, 1945. File location: Jerusalem, Yad Vashem, file number TR 10/2584 (in German).
- Statement of Luise E, Wasserburg, Germany, 19 June 1961. File location: Staatsarchiv München, file number 33.029/2 (in German).
- Statement of Otto Freund, 4 December 1964, Landesgericht, Frankfurt. File location: Staatsarchiv München, file number 33.029/3 (in German).
- Statement of Hedwig Vollheim, 10 February 1960, Bavarian Criminal Police, Munich. File location: Staatsarchiv München, file number 33.029/1 (in German).
- de Mildt D. In the name of the people: perpetrators of genocide in the reflection of their post-war prosecution in West Germany. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1996: 65.
- Memorial Chamber at Obrzyce, 2005.
- The Criminal Case Against Hilde Wernicke and Helene Wieczorek, 24 August 1946. File location: Staatsarchiv München, file number 33/029/1 (in German).
- Arendt H. Introduction. In: Naumann B. Auschwitz. New York: Praeger, 1966: xi.
- Letter to the court from Merkenschlager K, 1 March 1965. File location: Staatsarchiv München, file number 33.029/7 (in German).
- Statement of Anna G, 14 November 1961, Landesgericht, Traunstein. File location: Staatsarchiv München, file number 33.029/2 (in German).
- Statement of Martha W, 5 Feb 1962, Landesgericht, Traunstein. File location: Staatarchiv München, file number 33.029/2 (in German).
- Statement of Erna D [no date given]. File location: Staatarchiv München, file number 33.029/2 (in German).
- Statement of Margarete T, 10 April 1962, Landesgericht, München. File location: Staarchiv München, file number 33.029/3 (in German).
- Statement of Meta P, 16 Nov 1961, Lunesburg police station. File location: Staatsarchiv München, file number 33.029/3 (in German).
- Statement of Berta H, 20 Nov 1961, Hamburg police station. File location: Staatsarchiv München, file number 33.029/3 (in German).
- Statement of Margarete Maria M, 12 Dec 1962, Andernach police station. File location: Staatsarchiv München, file number 33.029/4 (in German).
- Statement of Gertrude F, 2 July 1962, Husum police station. File location: Staatsarchiv München 33.029/4 (in German).
- The Reich's Law Review, Part I: Law for the Reorganization of Nursing of 28 September 1938.
- Reich W. The care-based ethic of Nazi medicine and the moral importance of what we care about. Am J Bioeth 2001; 1: 68-69.
- Richarz B. Heilen, Pflegen, Töten. (To heal, to nurse, to kill.) Göttingen: Verlag für Medizin 1987: 188 (in German).
- Caplan A. When medicine went mad. Totowa, NJ: Humana Press, 1992.
- Caplan A. Medicine's shameful past. Lancet 2004; 363: 1741-42.[CrossRef]
- Caplan A. Too hard to face. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law 2005; 33: 394-400.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Lifton R. Doctors and torture. N Engl J Med 2004; 351: 415.[Free Full Text]
Nursing Ethics, Vol. 14, No. 6,
781-794 (2007)
DOI: 10.1177/0969733007082118
 CiteULike  Complore  Connotea  Del.icio.us  Digg  Reddit  Technorati  Twitter What's this?
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|
|
|
 
C. Giese
German Nurses, Euthanasia and Terminal Care: a Personal Perspective
Nursing Ethics,
March 1, 2009;
16(2):
231 - 237.
[Abstract]
[PDF]
|
|
|
|
|
